Documentary Analysis Of Control Room

Documentary Analysis Of Control Room In March 2003, American and British forces invaded Iraq with the intention to overthrow the regime of the dictator Saddam Hussein, and the Gulf War erupts. The countless military troops and thousands of journalists from all around the world, descend upon the region in order to secure potential news coverage. Truth ultimately finds its way to peoples eyes and ears and hearts. This is the sentence, uttered by Secretary of Defence Donald H. Rumsfeld, and is heard midway through Control Room Jahane Noujaims bristling documentary about Al Jazeera, the satellite news network during the war. You can only hope that Mr. Rumsfeld is right, though his words inevitably call to mind the proverb, that in war, truth is the first casualty. (Scott, 2004; commondreams.com). Jehane Noujaims Control Room another high profile entrant in the current sweepstakes of anti-Bush, anti- imperialist documentaries. As in her Start up.com, Noujaim focuses less on abstract issues and more on the personalities of the players as they react to events taking place. She was born and raised in Egypt before moving to America and that is probably one of the reasons of her unusual access and trust on both sides. Al- Jazeera (one of the most popular channel in the Middle East with over 40 million Arab viewers) was launched in 1996. This observational documentary records the wide range of opinions that surrounds the Qatar television news network during Iraq invasion. Turning up at the stations headquarters in Qatar, Noujaim got to know reporter Hassan Ibrahim and senior producer Sameer Khadar, both from Al- Jazeera channel network, whose sympathy to her project enabled its success. Most of the ordinary people including journalists, who come into view in the documentary film are doubtful, to say the least of the Bush administrations policies, but they also stick to a journalistic ethic of objectivity and fairness, trying to navigate between their political allegiances and the code of their craft. (Walters, New York Times 2004) This particular documentary film is made of conversations of journalists and different people involved in the news industry. Though there are shots of dead civilians and bombardments with meat corpses, it is not the main subject in the film. The main subject is the real documentary shots showing people, journalists and their reaction to the events, their conversations and their actions. The shots of innocent Iraqi civilians being killed make the viewer feel very sorry for everything that is happening to them and their families. Therefore, the complete documentary film represents American military troops in the cruel and very devil light. An Observational documentary mode: This film uses a fly on the wall technique to observe the Al Jazeera journalists (and other media organisations) as they record stories and interact with the U.S. military media spokespersons. The main commentator in the name of Al Jazeera is the senior producer Sameer Khader. Conversation between the two organizations, which are Al Jazeera and US Central Command, is embodied in the interview between two individuals Hassan Ibrahim and the American press officer Lt. Rushing. Their conversations focus around conflict and the reason of the war, agendas and images and privy to many debates about neutrality and objectivity.In the observational documentary, the camera crew is not normally seen. The people who are being filmed are meant to forget, that the camera crew is there, this is aimed to give to the audience a slice of reality. (Predovnik, 2009 http/socio-political-documentaries. suite) The observational mode (as technology advanced by the 1960s and cameras became smaller and lighter, able to document life in a less intrusive manner, there is less control required over lighting etc, leaving the social actors free to act and the documentaries free to record without interacting with each other). (www.mediaknowall.com/Documentary/definitions.htm) Despite being seen as the most direct form of a documentary film, there are a number of problems inherent in the genre, which has caused to be viewed with some suspicion. One of the main problems centres on the extent to which `verite` can be seen as offering a `real` or `true` picture of the subject it is involved in. Lukacs, for example has claimed that the cameras attention to the `here and now` is an inadequate mode of knowing. Events and objects are all caught in process of change and networks of causal relations that require representation, if the `true` story is to be understood. Lukacs claim, however that the extensive totality of reality is beyond the scope of any artistic creation. In short, he is implying that `verite` is incapable of offering a true picture of its subject, because as an approach to documentary it is so limited in its scope. (Praxis international issue: 1/1986 p 82-94) Within the context of this piece of work, I am going to look on how editing can and does affect my documentary film. Editing can be defined as the art of being able to tell a story by connecting a series of shots together to make a sequence and thereby having a series of shots put together make a whole film. When editing is done well, it creates a continuity of sequence, which can make the film interesting and watchable. The way in which the camera is used, its many movements and angels of vision in relation to the object being photographed, the speed in which it reproduces actions and the very appearance of person and things before it, are governed by the many ways in which editing is fulfilled. (Rotha, 1966:79) In this particular documentary film, I have focused on the details of the opening scenes in the different aspects, whether it is a sound, camera angels or emotional influences, and if to pay attention, it is easy to see and understand the scenes and the way that the director expresses the key moments by using very sad music, dialogues and actions. Dialogues between the journalists and some other people related to the war story within the film are very crucial and important in order to follow the story. Those conversations give you a brief explanation of what is going on and who is probably the victim in the story. However, director of the film knew how to send a message to the viewer and most of all what kind of message, by finishing it all with a very clever and very provocative angle of editing in this film. There are two scenes in this film, which I would like to highlight. One of them is when, on the fifteenths minute of the documentary, the director has showed us the archive footage of ordinary, unarmed, innocent people being humiliated and attacked by the U.S military troops right in their houses. The second scene, when the statue of Saddam Hussein being removed on the square and when people shown to us, are very cheerful about it, in my opinion, gives a very strong evidence of what director was trying to say in this documentary. Most importantly, when several journalists give us their thoughts and views about the moment, when this is all happening on the square, is vital for the whole structure of the film. That is probably, the essential part in order to understand and make your own `truth` about this documentary film. By the end of Control Room documentary, viewers make their own conclusion. In fact, in this documentary, we have been given a `truth`, which every single viewer will decide for him/her self. We are also presented with filmic evidence, in which Al Jazeera is keen to show both sides of an argument and engage in lots of discussions, including the airing of an American perspective. In my view, the editing of the shots and conversations, along with interviews, wounded pictures of children, played a key role in this documentary.

Discussion Assignment On Learning Styles And Gagnes Theory

The Divergers take the experiences and they think profoundly about them, the diverging from a lone experience to the multiple possibilities is in footings of what it might intend. And they are like to inquire the inquiry ‘why ‘ , and they will get down from the item to the constructive work which is up to the large image. They besides enjoy in take parting and in working with the others but they are like a composure of the ship and they fret over the struggles. The Divergers are usually influenced by the other citizens and them like in having a constructive type of feedbacks. The Divergers like to larn through the logical direction or by the hands-one geographic expedition with the conversations which will take to the find. ( Rickettes )Convergers:The convergers consider about the things and so merely seek out in their thoughts in order to see if they can work in pattern. They ever like to inquire the inquiry ‘how ‘ about the state of affairss, they have good understanding of the things as how effects work in pattern. The convergers like the facts and they will seek to do the things efficient in doing minute and cautious alterations. They wish to work with themselves, they believing really carefully and like moving really autonomously. The Convergers learn through the interaction and have a computer-based instruction which is more efficient than the other methods learned by them.Accomodators:The obligers have most of the hands-on the attacks, with a brawny preference which is for making instead than for believing. They all like to inquire the inquiry ‘what if? ‘ and besides ‘why non? ‘ in order to back up their action-for their first attack. Convergers do non like the modus operandi and will take artistic hazards in order to see what is traveling to go on. They really much like to research the complexness by the direct interface and to larn healthier by them than with the other peoples. As they might be anticipati ng this because they like their custodies to be in the practical acquisition ‘s instead than on the talks.Learners:The learners are holding the most cognitive type of attacks ; they prefer to believe than to move. Learners like to inquire the inquiries like ‘What is at that place I can cognize? ‘ and they like the organized and the structured type of apprehensions. The learners prefer the talks for larning and with the procedure of presentations where it is possible, and it will be esteeming the cognition of the experts. Learners will besides be larning through the conversations that will take a logical and a thoughtful type of attack. So it is really much clear for how to plan the plans for these types. The designing of theseA developing programsA can be undertaken merely when there is a clear construct for the preparation of the aims which has been formed. The readying aims is clears to what the end has to be gained till the stoping of the preparation plans that is what the trainees are to be unsurprising to be able to finish at the stoping of their preparation programs.A The preparation objectivesA ever help the trainers for the designing of the preparation of the plans. The different schemes should be laid down for the different sorts of the trainees for those who are believing in theories should hold those sort of plans and the scholars who believe in practical cognition for them patterns should be organized and the overall decisions which comes is that the cantonments should hold an overall plan procedure which should get down from theories to the patterns. ( Kirkpatrick ‘s foour-level preparation rating theoretical account, 2010 )Learning spheres:First of all, Gagne ‘s theory does supply a great trade of valuable information to instructors and the trainers. The celebrated Robert Gagne ‘s had a theory for the direction that has provided a immense whole number of cherished thoughts to the instructional the interior decorators, the trainers, and the instructors but it truly really utile to everyone during all times. Driscoll has broken the Gagne ‘s theory into three major or countries which are the taxonomy for the larning ty pe of results, the conditions of acquisition, and the events of learning Harmonizing to my belief it is the most appealing manner for those trainees or the trainers who may be really early in their instruction callings and now they are in the demand of the construction for their session sort of programs and holding a holistic sight of their instruction or for the development of the preparation plans. The given sort of theory is in really methodical and inflexible at the bulk of the points. However, by the methodical environment of the hypothesis it may be like a turn-off for many of the preparation plans, and peculiarly for all those developing plans which are like to be originative. ( Kirkpatrick ‘s four degree of rating )Gagne ‘s TheoryAs earlier explained the Gagne ‘s theory of the instruction is normally wrecked into the three Fieldss. The first one of these Fieldss is discussed under the terminology of the larning type of results. The Gagne ‘s taxonomy f or the instruction type of results is like slightly comparable with the Bloom ‘s taxonomy type of the cognitive, emotional, and the psychomotor outcomes where some of the taxonomies were projected by theory of Bloom, but in fact it is completed by the others. Gagne supposed that it was important to nail down the worlds who learned the capablenesss into the classs or the spheres. The gagne ‘s taxonomy is dwelling of the five classs for the educational consequences like the verbal type of information, the rational sort of accomplishments, the cognitive type of schemes, the attitudes, and the motor accomplishments. Gagne with the aid of Briggs and Wager in the year1992 clarified that each of these classs had leads to the different categories of the human public presentation under the counsel plans. Indispensable to the Gagne ‘s thoughts of the direction where he calls the â€Å" conditions of the acquisition ‘s † and he differentiated these thoughts into the internal and the external type of fortunes. The 1 with the internal fortunes trade with earlier erudite accomplishments of the scholar. In the other words, it can be said that what the novice knows old to the preparation plans. The present external fortunes have to cover with the strictly behaviouristic type of term that is presented externally to the novice. For illustration: What sort of instructions is provided to the trainee? So there were the procedures or the ways by which Robert classified the result system. And all his procedure is really relevant in developing the preparation plans. So we can reason that Gagne had a immense and huge part in the development of the preparation plans. ( Cunningham, 1996 )Training Evaluation:Kirkpatrick ‘s four degree theoretical accounts for the rating of the preparation plans are:Level One – Chemical reaction:As the word itself implies, that the rating at this degree measures for how the scholars do respond with the preparation plans. The degree is really frequently measured by the attitude of questionnaires that are approved out after the most of the preparation categories. This degree of it measures one thing that is the scholar ‘s perceptual experience or the reaction for the classs. The scholars are really frequently keenly cognizant for what they require to necessitate to cognize in order to carry through the undertakings. If this plan fails to satisfy their demands, so a finding should be completed as to whether it ‘s the duty of the plan program or release. ( Four acquisition manners, 2011 ) This degree is non merely declarative for the preparation ‘s presentation of the possible as it do non mensurate what the new accomplishments does the scholars have gained or what they will hold to larn so that it will reassign back to the working type of milieus. This has lead to do some of the judges for the down drama of its values. The involvement, motive and the attending of the participants which are frequently really critical with the success of any of the preparation procedure which the people frequently learn enhanced when they respond positively to the instruction environment by sing the significance of it. ( Using kolb ‘s acquisition manners to better a lesson, 2011 )Level Two – Learning:This is the lone extent at which the participants have alteration in the attitudes, with improved cognition, and their addition in the accomplishment as an consequence of engagement in the cognition procedure or in the cantonments. It to boot addresses this inquiry thatA did the people who were participants learned anything? A This acquisition of the rating requires some of the types of post-testing in order to determine with what sort of accomplishments were erudite during the clip of preparation. And in add-on, to the post-testing it is merely valid until combined with the pre-testing, so that the trainees can separate between what they antecedently knew predating to the preparation plans and what they have really learned in the preparation plan. ( Condition of larning ) In measurement of the acquisition ‘s that have taken topographic point in a preparation program is really of import in array to authenticate the acquisition of the aims. The rating of the acquisition that has taken topographic point will typically concentrate on such type of inquiries as: What sort of cognition was gained? ( Lacin, 2011 ) What type of accomplishments were enhanced or developed? What attitudes were to be changed? ( Robert ‘s Gagne ‘s Instructional Design Approach, 2011 ) The scholar appraisals are to be created in order to let the judgements which are to be made for the scholar ‘s capablenesss of the public presentation. There have been two parts for this type of procedure foremost the fold of the information or the grounds which is the testing of the scholar and in the judgement of the information like what does this information represent. The assessment should non be puzzled withA the rating. The appraisal is all about for the advancement and the accomplishments of the entity scholars, while the rating is all about the acquisition of the plan as a whole. ( Gagne )Level Three – Performance ( behavior ) :This type of rating fundamentally involves in the testing of the pupils capablenesss to put to death the erudite accomplishments during the occupation to a certain extent than in the schoolroom. The degree three ratings could be performed really officially proving or which are informally in the surveillance. It so determines that if ther e is right public presentation now go oning by replying of the inquiries ( david a. kolb on experiental acquisition, 2001 ) â€Å" Do people utilize their freshly acquired acquisition ‘s on the occupation? † While in the Kirkpatrick ‘s alone four-levels of the rating, the names for this degree of public presentation but the behaviour is the lone action that is done, while in the concluding consequence of this behaviour it is the public presentation. ( The kirkpatrick four degrees: A fresh expression after 50 old ages 1959-2009, 2009 ) The public presentations have two facets foremost the public presentation being the gross and its consequence being the terminal. If the one traveling to form the preparation were merely concerned about the behavioural type facet, so it could merely be done when in the preparation milieus. The result of the actions or the public presentation is what people are really after and the inquiry is â€Å" can the scholars now execute and produce the wanted consequences in the operational environment? † ( Reiser, 2005 )Level Four – Consequences:This is the concluding consequences that occur. It merely measures the preparation plans and its effectivity, that is, â€Å" What type of impact has the preparation achieved? † These impacts can be taken in history of such points such as the pecuniary, the efficiency, its moral, the teamwork, etc. ( Training Design, 2007 ) As we have moved from degree one to the degree four, so the appraisal procedure becomes more and more difficult and tarriance ; nevertheless, if the higher degree provides the information that is of bit by bit more important value. But possibly the most regularly type of measuring is the level-on. It ‘s vitamin E because it is the easiest manner to mensurate, but yet it provides the slightest valuable informations. Measurement of the consequences that affect the association is frequently significantly trickier, therefore it is conducted fewer often, even though it yields the bulk cherished information. ( Kirkpatrick ‘s acquisition and trainign rating theory, 2009 ) So, all these steps helped a batch in the preparation plans. ( Kolb larning manner, 2010 )

Is conflict a key aspect of family life? Essay

Conflict is indeed a key aspect of family life. It happens on a daily basis in almost every home in the country; even the Waltons had conflict with each other. I have the view that conflict is a corner stone of our life; it can help bring us together, not just drive us apart. During Flight this is particularly apparent, but in Your shoes conflict seems to have a negative effect. At the beginning of Flight the ‘old man’ seems to be looking for conflict; â€Å"‘Hey! ‘ he shouted; saw her jump†¦ ‘Waiting for Steven, hey?’ he said, his fingers curling like claws into his palm. † Within thirty lines Lessing had set the scene for the family tension and demonised the old man. As Flight progresses we find out that the old man only causes the conflict in an effort to retain his last granddaughter, which removes most of the negative feeling. The turning point, the point where the old man’s conflict is lost, is central to the story; â€Å"On the wrist of the post master’s son balanced a young pigeon, the light gleaming on its breast. ‘For me?’ said the old man, letting the drops shake of his chin. ‘For me? ‘† The relationship brought the granddaughter and her mother together because they were both united against the old man, but when the post master’s son gives him the bird as a peace offering he lets go of his anger and is drawn closer to his family, even though his family is moving further away. The repetition of ‘For me? ‘ is the strongest indicator of this new found peace with his family, showing his sincerity and to an extent his acceptance of the marriage of his granddaughter. In Your shoes the opposite of Flight happens. The conflict of the father aimed at the girl and the girl aimed at the mother was all bottled up, until a small and almost insignificant fuse was lit. Your shoes is narrated only by the mother so we get a very bias account of events leading up to the daughter’s departure. We mainly have to read between the lines and make assumptions, such as the daughter and mother often rowed. However there are brief accounts which seem to be the real truth and not just the mother’s perception; â€Å"You’ve got to understand. When your father called you a dirty slut he didn’t mean you to take it personally. It was just a manner of speaking. In the heat of the moment. He adores you, you know that. † Here the mother tackles the main reason for her daughter’s exit and defends it. She first clears him of any blame and then claims he loves her. I feel from her explanation that she almost doesn’t believe it her self because of her short snappy and almost panicky sentences. In conclusion I believe that conflict is common in family life and Flight and Your shoes are just two of hundreds of short stories which try to convey the subject. Flight shows a better side of conflict where it is resolved peacefully and ultimately brings the family closer, where as Your shoes attempts to convey an uglier side to conflict, resulting in distancing the father and the daughter and turning the mother into a nervous wreck not knowing what to believe.

Decision Making As A Deliberate Conscious Essay - 1799 Words

Introduction Decision making is one of the most complicated processes of the human brain where the intervention of several factors produces different results (Lizà ¡rraga, Baquedane Cardelle-Elawar, 2007). As defined by Harris (1980) â€Å"Decision making is the study of identifying and choosing alternatives based on the values and preferences of the decision maker†. Also, Shull et al. (1970) defines decision making as a deliberate conscious effort that involve individual and social differences (as cited in Al-Tarawneh, 2012). In order to make a decision, there are several steps that must be followed in which Baker et al.(2001) specifies as defining the problem, determining the requirements the problem should meet, establishing goals to solve the problem, identifying alternatives, defining the criteria of the goals, selecting a decision making tool, evaluating alternatives against the criteria, and finally validating the solution chosen against the posed problem (as cited in Fà ¼là ¶p, n.d.). Moreover, this entire process is affected by several factors that can be personal, non-personal, environmental, etc. Halbert (1998) states that the fatigue, thirst, excessive heat deteriorates cognitive skills. For instance, according to Wright (1974), â€Å"Under time stress, decision-making performance deteriorated when more, rather than less information was provided†. Additionally, Cohen and Freeman (1996) claim that â€Å"More experienced decision makers buy themselves more time for resolvingShow MoreRelatedMethods Of Using Numerical Uncertainty Information Essay1555 Words   |  7 PagesDeliberate thinking. Limitations in the ability to utilize numerical uncertainty information could also be more general than numeracy, such as the failure to think deliberately about the information. According to the two systems approach, there are two modes of thought. System 1 is rapid, automatic, associative, emotional, and roughly synonymous with intuition, and System 2 is slow, deli berate, rule-based, and effortful (Kahneman, 2003). When faced with a decision, a person may substitute an inaccurateRead MoreWhy Are Numeric Uncertainty? Essay1719 Words   |  7 PagesHowever, numeric uncertainty may not be the best form of communication for all users. Most of the work described above was done using university undergraduate students as subjects. It is reasonable to assume the decisions made by this population would be similar to the general population, but there could be subgroups that would make better use of a categorical recommendation. Indeed, using the example of Hurricane Floyd, a majority of residents (64%) followed the evacuation warning, suggesting itRead MoreNumeracy : A Basic Understanding Of Numerical Concepts Essay798 Words   |  4 PagesNumeracy. A basic understanding of numerical concepts is an important part of informed decision making, especially if numerical information included. Thus it is critical to understand how numeracy, the mathematical equivalent to numeracy impacts the ability to make use of risk communication. Numeracy can be assessed through objective and subjective measures and is not just a measure of education (see Reyna, Nelson, Han Dieckmann, 2009, for a recent review). Research seems to suggest that higherRead MoreA Brief Note On The Global Nursing Shortage Essay1551 Words   |  7 Pagesby his or her current employer. It is a conscious wilfulness to leave the organization on the employee’s own wills. It is thought that turnover intentions lead to an actual turnover (Osman et al., 2016). Turnover intention is a powerful predictor of an employee’s future behavior and actual turnover. The intention to leave is an individual’s view that he/she would leave the organization and is viewed as the absolute last stage in the decision-making process of an employee to look for otherRead MoreIs It Responsible For His Behaviors Either Good Or Bad?907 Words   |  4 PagesThe question whether one is responsible for his behaviors either good or bad because he has free will to decide what to do or don’t versus he has no moral responsibility for his behaviors because every act is pre-determined by his brain beyond his conscious control is definitely one of the controversial questions of today raised by psychologists, philosophers, neurologists and many others. According to the deterministic idea, everything happening is really the only thing that could happen in that circumstancesRead MoreIs It Responsible For His Behaviors Either Good Or Bad?886 Words   |  4 PagesThe question whether one is responsible for his behaviors either good or bad because he has free will to decide what to do or don’t versus he has no moral responsibility on his behaviors because every act is pre-determined by his brain beyond his conscious control is definitely one of the controversial questions of today raised by psychologists, philosophers, neurologists and many others. According to the deterministic idea, everything happening is really the only thing that could happen in that circumstancesRead MoreAnalysis Of Daniel Kahneman s Thinking Fast And Slow Essay1648 Words   |  7 Pagesshocking, that the percentage of favorable rulings dropped gradually to nearly zero within each decision session and returned abruptly to around 65% after a break. This is illustrated in the diagram below, where dotted lines indicate food breaks. This was after accounting for different variables and checking for alternative explanations. This goes to show that the human mind is limited. Even moral decisions made by highly educated individuals cannot escape the curse of mental fatigue as shown by theRead MoreDeliberate Cruelty By Edgar Allen Poe Essay1514 Words   |  7 PagesDeliberate Cruelty is not Madness Edgar Allen Poe is infamous for his works hat features violence, madness, death among other dark themes. His texts â€Å"The Black Cat† and â€Å"The Telltale Heart† are not different. Both of the narrators committed murder and justify their reasoning behind their madness and their heinous crimes. The former killed his wife in an attempt to kill the black cat and the latter killed the old man because of his evil eye. They both attempted to hide the bodies, but ultimatelyRead MoreChapter 8 : Behavioral Economics1490 Words   |  6 Pagesand to better correct my decisions based off any of the biases and/or heuristics that I may be affected by, especially inadvertently. Also, it just burns my curiosity, very deeply, to understand behavior from a very macro view of society and humans. To begin with, System 1 is the automatic, emotional, intuitive part of our brain. The part that creates first impressions, makes us feel our emotions, and other ingrained habitual tasks- and thoughts- that require no conscious effortful thinking. ItRead MoreComparison Between Planning and Design School1476 Words   |  6 Pagesconception. It’s a clear and unique strategies are formulated in a deliberate process. In this process, the internal situation of the organization is matched to the external situation of the environment. The original view sees strategy formation as achieving the essential fit between internal strengths and weaknesses and external threats and opportunities. Senior management formulates clear and simple strategies in a deliberate process of conscious thought - which is neither formally analytical nor informally